Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics, Umami, Matomo, GA4 or Lomen? How to choose

There's no single best analytics tool for a small site. Six questions narrow the field: what it stores, how it counts visitors, events, hosting, limits and install. Then seven tools, Lomen included, with who each one fits and where it stops.

10 min read

Summarize with

In this article
  1. 1Six questions to answer first
  2. 2The seven tools side by side
  3. 3Plausible
  4. 4Fathom
  5. 5Simple Analytics
  6. 6Umami
  7. 7Matomo
  8. 8Google Analytics 4
  9. 9Where Lomen fits, and where it doesn't
  10. 10Switching without losing your bearings
  11. 11Sources

There's no best analytics tool, only one that fits your site and the questions you'll ask of it. A side project that needs a visitor count, a product that tracks signups and a site that must keep its data in the EU want different things.

Below are six questions that narrow the field, a comparison table and a section per tool. We make Lomen, so it gets its own section, including what it doesn't do. Facts about the other six come from their own pages, checked on 2026-11-17 and listed at the end.

Six questions to answer first

What does it store in the browser?

GA4 and Matomo set first-party cookies by default, and Matomo can be switched to cookieless mode. The other five set none from their standard script. That's much of the consent question, not all of it.

How does it count a unique visitor?

A cookie can recognise someone for months. A daily hash can't link Monday to Tuesday, and one tool here builds no identifier at all. So the same traffic gives different visitor counts in different tools.

Do you need events or funnels?

Signups and purchases take custom events, and seeing where people drop off takes funnels. The tools differ most here, often by plan, so check the plan you'd pay for.

Hosted, or your own server?

Self-hosted software can be free, but you run the server, database, updates and backups. On a hosted plan, check where the data is stored.

What are the limits?

For a small site, sampling rarely comes up. You'll run into other limits first: what counts toward the allowance (custom events often do), how much history a plan keeps and which features need a higher tier.

How much work is the install?

All seven start with a script snippet added to every page. On a single-page app, as many Lovable, Bolt and v0 sites are, click through a few pages to check each is counted. The builder guide shows where the tag goes.

Here's how each tool counts a unique visitor, from its own documentation:

ToolWhat stands in for a personHow long it lasts
GA4A client ID in the _ga cookieTwo years by default. Browsers cut it short for people who don't return: 400 days in Chrome, 7 days in Safari
Matomo, defaultA visitor ID in the _pk_id cookie13 months
Matomo, cookielessA hash of operating system, browser, plugins, IP address and languageUp to 24 hours
UmamiA hash of the website, IP address, user agent and a saltUntil the salt rotates: monthly by default. Self-hosters can set daily, weekly or a fixed salt that never rotates
Plausible, Fathom, Lomen by defaultA hash of the site, IP address, user agent and a daily saltOne day
Lomen, opt-in modeA random token in browser storageAcross days
Simple AnalyticsNothing. A pageview counts as a visitor when it comes from another site or with no referrerOne visit. The next entry from outside counts again

Someone who visits on three days in a month, from the same browser and network, can be one visitor to GA4, cookie-based Matomo and Umami, and three to Plausible, Fathom and Lomen in its default mode. None of them is wrong. The guide to counting unique visitors without cookies shows where each method miscounts.

The seven tools side by side

One row per tool, in two tables: where it runs first, then what it costs and does. The sections below give the conditions and the prices.

ToolHostingOpen sourceCookies from the tracking script by default
PlausibleCloud (Germany) or self-hostedCommunity Edition yes, AGPLv3None
FathomCloud only. US storage, EU IPs handled in the EUNo. The older Fathom Lite is MITNone
Simple AnalyticsCloud only (Netherlands)No. Tracking scripts are MITNone, and no visitor ID
UmamiCloud (US or EU region) or self-hostedYes, MITNone
MatomoCloud (Frankfurt) or self-hostedCore yes, GPLv3. Some paid plugins aren'tYes. Cookieless mode available
GA4Google's cloud onlyNoYes. With consent mode, none while consent is denied
LomenCloud only. No data region statedNoNone. An opt-in mode stores a browser token
ToolFree optionCustom events and funnelsAI chat or MCP
PlausibleSelf-hosting. Cloud: 30-day trialEvents on every plan. Funnels on Business, not self-hostedNo chat found. Community MCP only
FathomNo. 7-day trialEvents on every plan. No funnels in its docsLuna chat. No official MCP found
Simple AnalyticsFree plan, with a badge and no eventsEvents and goals on paid plans. Funnels as aggregate stepsOfficial MCP on every plan. Older opt-in chat
UmamiSelf-hosting, or Cloud Hobby for one siteBoth, on every plan and self-hostedOfficial MCP from Pro, or self-hosted. No chat found
MatomoSelf-hosting. Cloud: 21-day trialEvents built in. Funnels on Cloud, or a paid plugin self-hostedOfficial MCP. Ask Matomo chat announced for November 2026
GA4Yes, standard GA4 is freeBoth, freeAsk Advisor chat (beta). Google's MCP server
LomenFree during the public betaNeitherLomen AI chat. Official read-only MCP

Plausible

Plausible's script, according to its data policy, sets no cookies and writes nothing to the visitor's device. Plausible Cloud stores visitor data in Falkenstein, Germany, and a free Community Edition can be self-hosted under AGPLv3. Since June 2026 the Channels report has an AI Assistants channel.

  • Who it fits. Site owners who want a simple dashboard on European infrastructure, or to self-host. Goals and custom events are on every plan.
  • Price. No free cloud plan, but a 30-day trial without a card. Starter is $9 a month for one site and 10,000 monthly pageviews, and Business is $19 at that tier (pricing, as of 2026-11-17). Custom events count toward the tier.
  • Where it stops. On the cloud, funnels, revenue goals and the Stats API need the Business plan. Funnels and revenue goals are also left out of the Community Edition, which is released twice a year. There's no official MCP server. The docs point to a community one built by the Sentry team, which needs a Stats API key.

Fathom

Fathom is a hosted dashboard that sets no cookies. Unique visitors come from a hash with a daily salt. EU visitors' IP addresses are processed and stripped on EU servers, and the anonymized analytics are stored in the US. Every plan has the same features, including 50 sites and an API. Since October 2026, Luna, an AI assistant, answers questions about Fathom and, once you allow it, about your stats (messages go to Anthropic), and an AI tab shows visitors from AI tools.

  • Who it fits. Small businesses and agencies with several sites who want one simple hosted dashboard.
  • Price. No free plan, and the 7-day trial needs a card. From $15 a month for 100,000 monthly pageviews across all sites (pricing, USD, as of 2026-11-17). Events and API requests count toward it.
  • Where it stops. Its docs don't mention funnels, and its help centre says undocumented features don't exist. The current product can't be self-hosted. The older Fathom Lite can, but its README says it uses cookies.

Simple Analytics

Simple Analytics stores its data in the Netherlands and nothing on the visitor's device. It builds no visitor identifier: its “visitors” are unique pageviews, decided by the referrer, so returning visitors are never recognised. The dashboard isn't open source; the tracking scripts are, under MIT. Its official MCP server works on every plan, Free included, and asks before it changes anything. An older AI chat is opt-in and sends aggregated data to OpenAI.

  • Who it fits. Sites that want EU storage and the least possible data about visitors.
  • Price. A free plan with five sites, one month of history, a required badge and no events or APIs. Paid plans start at $15 a month for 20,000 pageviews and events (plain-text pricing, as of 2026-11-17). The main page shows your local currency.
  • Where it stops. No unique or returning visitor counts in the usual sense, funnels are aggregate filters, and its docs describe no revenue report. It can't be self-hosted, and its own comparison page points people who need that to Plausible.

Umami

Umami is MIT-licensed. Run it on Umami Cloud, with a US or EU data region, or on your own server with Node.js and PostgreSQL. The tracker sets no cookies, and the salt in its visitor hash rotates monthly by default. Custom events, goals, funnels, journeys, retention and revenue reports are on every Cloud plan and in the self-hosted version. Its MCP server is official and read-only.

  • Who it fits. Developers and small teams who want events and funnels without cookies, free on their own server or on a hosted free tier.
  • Price. Hobby is $0 for 100,000 events a month on one site, with six months of history and no API or MCP. Pro is $20 a month for one million events (pricing, as of 2026-11-17). Pageviews, custom events and event properties all count.
  • Where it stops. On Cloud, the API, MCP and more than one site start at Pro. Email reports and integrations such as Search Console aren't in the self-hosted version.

Matomo

Matomo is a full suite in the style of Google Analytics, with events, goals, ecommerce and reports that aren't sampled. The GPLv3 core runs on your own server with PHP and MySQL or MariaDB, or on Matomo Cloud in Frankfurt. By default it sets first-party cookies, including a 13-month visitor ID, and you can turn them off per site or for all sites. An official MCP server comes with Cloud and is a free plugin On-Premise. A built-in chat, Ask Matomo, is announced for November 2026. On 2026-11-17 Matomo's pages still described it as coming.

  • Who it fits. Organisations that want a Google Analytics-style suite and to own their data.
  • Price. On-Premise Community is free, and paid plugin bundles start at €230 a month billed yearly, or €275 month to month. Cloud has a 21-day trial, then starts at €22 a month excluding tax for 50,000 hits (pricing, as of 2026-11-17), shown in your local currency.
  • Where it stops. In cookieless mode, Matomo says unique and returning visitor counts become inaccurate. Self-hosted, funnels and heatmaps are paid plugins. Leaving Matomo? See choosing a Matomo alternative.

Google Analytics 4

GA4 is free, hosted by Google, and covers events, funnels of up to 10 steps and ecommerce in depth, with raw export to BigQuery (up to 1 million events a day on standard properties; BigQuery bills beyond its free sandbox). Its tag sets first-party cookies by default, and _ga is set to last two years unless you change it, though browsers cut that short for people who don't return (Google cites 400 days in Chrome and 7 days in Safari). With consent mode in its advanced setup, visitors who decline are measured with cookieless pings (the basic setup sends nothing for them). GA4 can model their behaviour, but only on properties with at least 1,000 daily users who accept and 1,000 daily events from users who decline, for at least 7 days. Ask Advisor, a Gemini chat, is in beta for properties set to English, and Google documents an MCP server for read requests.

  • Who it fits. Businesses that want a free full suite, especially alongside Google Ads, and can handle the consent setup that comes with cookies.
  • Price. Free. The paid tier, Analytics 360, has no public price.
  • Where it stops. User counts are close estimates, queries over 10 million events can be sampled, and explorations and funnel reports only reach back 2 or 14 months on standard properties.

Where Lomen fits, and where it doesn't

We make Lomen, so weigh this section accordingly.

Lomen is a hosted dashboard of pageviews, visitors, pages, sources, countries and devices, with a live view of the last five minutes. The tracking script sets no cookies and by default stores nothing in the browser. Unique visitors come from a daily hash, and IP addresses are never written to Lomen's database. An opt-in With cookies mode keeps a random token in browser storage to recognise returning visitors. Lomen's cookie page says that mode needs a banner that asks first, and optional session recordings only run in it. Beyond the dashboard:

  • Lomen AI, a chat, answers questions about your own figures. Lomen computes baselines and outlier days, and Google Gemini writes the answer from those aggregated figures only, with a confidence level. While Lomen uses Gemini's free tier, Google may use what is sent to it to improve its own services.
  • An official MCP server lets Claude or ChatGPT read your site's figures through read-only tools, once you approve it.
  • Visits from nine AI assistants, matched by referrer and by utm_source, get a card of their own.
  • Revenue from Stripe, Shopify, Lemon Squeezy, Polar and Paystack is added together on the same chart as visitors.
  • The install is one script tag. On Lovable it's one prompt in the project's chat.

It's free during the public beta, with three AI insights a month. The planned pricing on the pricing page starts at $8 a month for up to 10,000 monthly pageviews across all your sites (as of 2026-11-17), and it is not final. What Lomen doesn't do:

  • Custom events, conversion goals or funnels.
  • Self-hosting or open source.
  • A stated data region.
  • A campaigns report on the dashboard. The script records UTM tags, and Lomen AI can break a day down by campaign, but there's no report to browse.
  • A public API. Data leaves by CSV export or the MCP server.
  • Revenue per channel. Revenue sits next to visitors by day.
  • Fixed prices or a long track record.

If any of those matters, another tool fits better:

If you needLook at
Custom events, goals or funnelsUmami (every plan, self-hosted too), Plausible (events on every plan, funnels on Business), Fathom (events on every plan), Simple Analytics (events and goals on paid plans), Matomo or GA4
Self-hosting or open sourceUmami, Plausible Community Edition or Matomo On-Premise
Data stored in the EUPlausible, Simple Analytics, Matomo Cloud or Umami Cloud's EU region
An analytics APIFathom (every plan), Simple Analytics (paid plans), Umami (Cloud Pro or self-hosted), Plausible (Business, or Community Edition), Matomo or GA4
Revenue by source or campaignUmami (revenue and attribution reports on every plan, payment integrations from Cloud Pro), Plausible's Business plan, Fathom (event revenue on every plan, filterable by campaign), Matomo's ecommerce reports or GA4's ecommerce events
No visitor identifier at allSimple Analytics

Weighing Lomen against one tool in particular? The comparison pages go row by row: Plausible, Fathom, Simple Analytics, Umami and Google Analytics.

Switching without losing your bearings

You don't have to switch in one go.

  1. Run both for two to four weeks. Add the new tag beside the old one and compare pageviews by day. A steady ratio means both work, even if totals differ.
  2. Expect unique visitors to differ, as the table near the top shows and the guide to counting unique visitors without cookies explains.
  3. Expect consent, bots and blockers to move the totals. Why no two analytics tools agree on your traffic covers those gaps.
  4. Keep your history. Export what you'll want before you cancel anything, and check whether the new tool imports it. Umami Cloud, for one, imports data from a self-hosted Umami instance or from CSV exports on Pro and up, and its team runs the import.
  5. Start a new trend line on the day you switch. Then remove the old tag and check that your privacy policy and any cookie banner match what the site loads.

Sources

Each vendor's own pages, all checked on 2026-11-17:

Numbers you can ask questions

Lomen is one tracking script that sets no cookies: pages, sources and AI referrals on one dashboard, and an AI that answers from your own figures. Free during the beta, no credit card.